Quranic Science

Family of the Heart - DIALOGUE & DISCUSSIONS 

Dr. Javed Jamil

It is true that the present day Qur’an is not in accordance with order of the revelations. It may or may not be true that Hadhrat Ali, the great Caliph and Imam had arranged it in the order of the revelations. But it is also true that

  1. The Qur’an is the same everywhere today and all the sects agree on it including the Shiites;
  2. Hadhrat Ali did not object to the order in which Qur’an was arranged; and he did never show to anybody the Qur’an he collected if he really did. He did not show it even in the days of his khilafah. It is clear that if he had any other collection, he did not think it right to show it, and he was fully convinced about the order of the verses of the authorised version of Qur’an;
  3. While revelation of Quranic verses was in accordance with the requirement of that particular time and suitability according to that timing; it is not necessary that the same order would suit the readers of the posterity. A writer can write different chapters at different times but when he compiles it in the end, the sequence of his writings is normally not the same in which he wrote;
  4.  more

127

Peter Joyce 

TO Feroz Karmally post # 126

Oct. 31, 2009

125

Feroz Karmally       

TO Peter Joyce post # 126

Oct. 31, 2009

126

Peter Joyce 

TO Feroz Karmally post # 125

Oct. 30, 2009

125

Feroz Karmally       

TO Peter Joyce post # 124

Oct. 29, 2009

124

Peter Joyce 

TO Feroz Karmally post # 123

Oct. 29, 2009

123

Feroz Karmally      

TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 122

Oct. 17, 2009

122

Dr. Javed Jamil       

TO Feroz Karmally post # 121

Oct. 17, 2009

121

Feroz Karmally       

TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 117

Oct. 16, 2009

120

Dr. Javed Jamil       

TO Rashid Mughal post # 118

Oct. 16, 2009

119

Feroz Karmally 

TO Rashid Mughal post # 115

Oct. 16, 2009

118

Rashid Mughal        

Atheism is also a religion

Oct. 16, 2009

117

Dr. Javed Jamil       

TO Rashid Mughal post # 115

Oct. 16, 2009

116

Rashid Mughal        

Conditioning and duality (2)

Oct. 16, 2009

115

Rashid Mughal       

A shoddy piece of work

Oct. 15, 2009

114

Rashid Mughal       

TO Dr Fazlur Rahman

Oct. 14, 2009

113 Dr Fazlur Rahman

TO Rashid Mughal

Oct. 14, 2009

112 Name withheld by request

TO Rashid Mughal

Oct. 14, 2009

111

Feroz Karmally 

TO Rashid Mughal post # 110

Oct. 14, 2009

 110

Rashid Mughal       

Conditioning and duality

Oct. 13, 2009

109

Feroz Karmally  

TO Rashid Mughal post # 108

Oct. 12, 2009

 108

Rashid Mughal       

God and His creation are one

Oct. 12, 2009

107

Feroz Karmally  

TO Rashid Mughal post # 106

Oct. 10, 2009

 106

Rashid Mughal       

A magnificent obsession

Oct. 10, 2009

105

Feroz Karmally  

TO Rashid Mughal post # 104

Oct. 08, 2009

 104

Rashid Mughal       

Let's leave God alone

Oct. 08, 2009

103

Feroz Karmally  

TO Zafar Rahmani post # 102

Oct. 08, 2009

102

Zafar Rahmani   

Feroz Karmally

Oct. 07, 2009

101

Mike Jackson     

 TO Zafar Rahmani post # 97

Oct. 07, 2009

100

Feroz Karmally 

TO Zafar Rahmani post # 098

Oct. 07, 2009

099

Feroz Karmally 

TO Zafar Rahmani post # 097

Oct. 07, 2009

098

Zafar Rahmani   

 Interesting Parallels

Oct. 07, 2009

097

Zafar Rahmani   

 TO Feroz Karmally & Mike Jackon

Oct. 06, 2009

096

Feroz Karmally  

TO Gary Dale post # 094

Oct. 06, 2009

095

Feroz Karmally  

TO Gary Dale post # 093

Oct. 06, 2009

094

Gary Dale      

 TO Feroz Kamally post # 091

Sep. 30, 2009

093

Gary Dale      

 TO Mike Jackson post # 090

Sep. 30, 2009

092

Feroz Karmally  

TO Mike Jackson Dale post # 090

Sep. 30, 2009

091

Feroz Karmally  

TO Gary Dale post # 089

Sep. 30, 2009

090

Mike Jackson      

 TO Gary Dale post # 87-89

Sep. 30, 2009

089

Gary Dale      

 TO Feroz Karmally post # 87

Sep. 30, 2009

088

Feroz Karmally  

TO Gary Dale post # 087

Sep. 30, 2009

087

Gary Dale      

 TO Feroz Karmally post # 86

Sep. 30, 2009

086

Feroz Karmally  

TO Gary Dale post # 083

Sep. 30, 2009

085

Aziz Ahmad     

 TO Family of the Heart

Sep. 28, 2009

084

Gary Dale     

 TO Javed Chaudry post # 79

Sep. 28, 2009

083

Gary Dale     

 TO Feroz Karmally post # 76

Sep. 28, 2009

082

Masud Sheikh  

 TO Rashid Mughal post # 77

Sep. 29, 2009

081

Feroz Karmally  

 TO Rashid Mughal post # 77

Sep. 29, 2009

080

Javed I. Chaudry     

TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 78

Sep. 28, 2009

079

Javed I. Chaudry     

TO Mr. Dale (post 63) and Dr. Jamil’s (post 54)

Sep. 28, 2009

078

Dr. Javed Jamil      

TO Gary Dale post # 063

Sep. 28, 2009

 077

Rashid Mughal      

Cease and desist

Sep. 28, 2009

076

Feroz Karmally  

 TO Rashid Mughal post # 70

Sep. 28, 2009

075

Dr. Akhter A. Khan

 TO Gary Dale & Dr. Javed Jamil

Sep. 28, 2009

074

Feroz Karmally  

 TO Gary Dale post # 71

Sep. 28, 2009

073

Dr. Akhter A. Khan    

 TO Dr. Khalid Sohail

Sep. 28, 2009

072

Gary Dale    

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 62

Sep. 28, 2009

071

Gary Dale   

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil 

Sep. 28, 2009

070

Rashid Mughal     

Truth needs no defence

Sep. 28, 2009

069

Rashid Mughal     

(Post has been removed by FOTH)

Sep. 28, 2009

068

Feroz Karmally 

 TO Gary Dale post # 63

Sep. 28, 2009

067

Feroz Karmally 

 TO Rashid Mughal post # 56

Sep. 28, 2009

066

Askari Naqvi  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil

Sep. 28, 2009

065

Dr. Javed Jamil     

TO Gary Dale post # 063

Sep. 28, 2009

064

Syed Imam Haider  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 062

Sep. 28, 2009

063

Gary Dale    

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil  post # 59

Sep. 28, 2009

062

Dr. Javed Jamil    

Dr. Syed Imam Haider post # 058

Sep. 28, 2009

061

Farooq Khalid Malik 

 TO Family of the Heart

Sep. 27, 2009

060

Peter Joyce 

 TO Syed Adil post # 47

Sep. 27, 2009

059

Dr. Javed Jamil    

To Gary Dale

Sep. 27, 2009

058

Syed Imam Haider 

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil

Sep. 27, 2009

057

Feroz Karmally 

 TO Rashid Mughal post # 56

Sep. 27, 2009

056

Rashid Mughal     

Self-righteous innocence

Sep. 27, 2009

055

Rashid Mughal     

Inspiration and the discovery of truth

Sep. 27, 2009

054

 Dr. javed jamil

To Gary Dale & Javed I. Chaudry

 Sep. 27, 2009

053

Feroz Karmally 

 TO Rashid Mughal post # 50

Sep. 27, 2009

052

Javed I. Chaudry    

Friends at FOTH

Sep. 27, 2009

051

Ziauddin Ahmed 

Friends at FOTH

Sep. 27, 2009

050

Rashid Mughal     

Like a cat on a hot tin roof

Sep. 27, 2009

049

Dr. Akhter A. Khan   

 TO syed Adil post # 047

Sep. 27, 2009

048

Feroz Karmally 

 TO Rashid Mughal post # 46

Sep. 26, 2009

047

Syed Adil     

TO Farzana Hassan

Sep. 26, 2009

046

Rashid Mughal     

Coming Soon: 'Witness A Miracle'

Sep. 26, 2009

045

Dr. Javed Jamil    

TO Feroz Karmally

Sep. 26, 2009

044

Dr. Javed Jamil    

TO Gary Dale

Sep. 26, 2009

043

Gary Dale   

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil 

Sep. 25, 2009

046

Javed I. Chaudry   

response to Dr. Jamil and Gary Dale

Sep. 23, 2009

045

Feroz Karmally  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil  post # 37

Sep. 25, 2009

044

Dr. Syed Shah Warsi  

 TO Mr. Amjad Chaudhry

Sep. 25, 2009

043

Gary Dale    

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil 

Sep. 25, 2009

042

Dr. Javed Jamil    

TO Gary Dale

Sep. 25, 2009

041

Dr. Syed Shah Warsi  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil

Sep. 25, 2009

040

Dr. Javed Jamil    

...questioning my right to give a theory

Sep. 25, 2009

039

Amjad Chaudhry  

TO Syed Shah Warsi  post # 20

Sep. 23, 2009

038

Rashid Mughal    

Do yourself a favour, Dr Jamil

Sep. 25, 2009

037

Dr. Javed Jamil    

To Gary dale

Sep. 25, 2009

036

Dr. Javed Jamil    

To Mohammed Gill

Sep. 25, 2009

035

Gary Dale   

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil 

Sep. 25, 2009

034

Mohammed Gill   

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil

Sep. 25, 2009

033

Gary Dale   

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil 

Sep. 24, 2009

032

Dr. Javed Jamil    

To Farzana Hassan & Mohammed Gill

Sep. 24, 2009

031

Gary Dale   

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil 

Sep. 24, 2009

030

Dr. Javed Jamil    

in support and against Einstein’s theories.

Sep. 24, 2009

029

Dr. Akhter A. Khan  

 TO Mr. Amjad Chaudhry

Sep. 24, 2009

028

Dr. Akhter A. Khan  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil

Sep. 24, 2009

027

Dr. Akhter A. Khan  

 TO Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy post # 021

Sep. 24, 2009

026

Farzana Hassan   

 TO Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy post # 021

Sep. 24, 2009

025

Dr. Javed Jamil    

 TO Farzana Hassan  post # 24

Sep. 24, 2009

024

Farzana Hassan   

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 022

Sep. 23, 2009

023

Mohammed Gill   

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil 

Sep. 24, 2009

022

Dr. Javed Jamil    

 TO Farzana Hassan 

Sep. 24, 2009

021

Pervez Hoodbhoy  

 TO Family of the heart

Sep. 24, 2009

020

Dr. Syed Shah Warsi  

 TO Amjad Chaudhry post # 016

Sep. 23, 2009

019

Dr. Javed Jamil  

 TO Farzana Hassan post # 018

Sep. 23, 2009

018

Farzana Hassan  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 010

Sep. 23, 2009

017

Farzana Hassan  

 TO Masud Sheikh post # 011

Sep. 23, 2009

016

Dr. Akhter A. Khan 

 TO FOTH of the Heart

Sep. 23, 2009

016

Amjad Chaudhry  

 TO FOTH & Dr. Akhtar Ali Khan

Sep. 23, 2009

015

Javed I. Chaudry  

 TO Farzana Hassan

Sep. 23, 2009

014

Farzana Hassan  

 TO Family of the Heart

Sep. 23, 2009

013

Javed I. Chaudry  

 TO Masud Sheikh post # 011

Sep. 23, 2009

012

Zafar Rahmani   

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 010

Sep. 23, 2009

011

Masud Sheikh    

 TO Farzana Hassan post # 009

Sep. 23, 2009

010

Dr. Javed Jamil    

 TO Farzana Hassan post # 009

Sep. 23, 2009

009

Farzana Hassan  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 007

Sep. 23, 2009

008

Javed I. Chaudry 

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 001

Sep. 22, 2009

007

Dr. Javed Jamil  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 006

Sep. 22, 2009

006

Zafar Rahmani  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 001

Sep. 22, 2009

005

Col. Anwar Ahmed 

 TO Farzana Hassan post # 002

Sep. 22, 2009

004

Mohammed Gill  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 001

Sep. 22, 2009

003

Col. Anwar Ahmed 

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 001

Sep. 22, 2009

002

Farzana Hassan  

 TO Dr. Javed Jamil post # 001

Sep. 21, 2009

001

Dr. Javed Jamil  

 TO Family of the Heart

Sep. 20, 2009

Send questions or comments to Family of the Heart