Mr. Chaudry,
It took you a long time to accept the truth, but in a candid
way: You finally said that...."I am fully aware of what has
transpired over the last fourteen centuries. I would prefer
to be part of the solution rather than part of the
problem".....
By saying what you said, you have acknowledged that there
are many "issues" with the religion, but it is better to
find a solution than to keep the rant "on" that there are
"issues". If that is the case, then we are all sailing in
the same boat, and share each other's aspirations. We are
all very keen to find a solution to this "screwup" and
develop a correct perspective and attitude, which integrates
humanity, rather than differentiates.
Your perspective, however, differs from ours. You, getting
inundated with too many facts, actually had nothing more to
say and got irritated. You are not willing to peep deep into
the "mindset" of the advocates of theology and ended your
sentence in a fiasco, by implying that....."I know it
all....don't tell me all these stories!!!....the house is on
fire....find a solution as this is not the time to discuss
what caused the fire".....
Having said that, all I wish to say further is that our
situation is of our own making....."is ghar ko aag lag gayee
ghar ke chiraagh se". Our text, like all other "holy" texts
have multiple embedded and implied meanings, as an example,
the meanings portrayed by Akhtar Shirazi are not the same as
Feroz Karmally, rather they are diametrically apart,
however, each of these guys claim that they have invested
thier life understanding the meaning of these
words............"WHO OF THESE TWO PORTRAY THE TRUTH?"
...Akhtar or Feroze or none of them. surely, both cannot be
right. Similarly, if you talk to different "men in the
street"in different locations, you will be amazed at the
polarity that exists at the level of thought and
solution......and I am not talking about the so called ...."aalim-e-deens",
who are much much more vehement about their own opinions.
In the opinion of the wise, the only solution is not to make
a cocktail of religion and state, as it was a disaster, is a
disaster and will always end in a disaster. Theological
problems can never be solved, social problem can. So when we
do ramification of our issues in our real world, the best
choice is to delink masjid and statehood, as both these have
no business with each other.
Everone will understand this.........sooner than later.
Najeeb Kazmi
March 29, 2006