Secular Jinnah

Family of the Heart - DIALOGUE & DISCUSSIONS 

 

Dear  Dr. Maqsood Jafri

 

You write:

 

“The non-believer means  that a person does not believe in God. So how it comes that you also name an un believer as a believer.”

 

 

The starting phrase in my earlier post is: “The base of any religion is “Belief”.

 

And I continued with “Since the non-existence of God is based on belief (without prove), so atheism is also a religion."

 

In Buddhism there is no God (atheism!) and in Hinduism an atheist is an integral part.

 

                    *******

 

In monotheism, to believe in one and unique God, is the only way to enter the religion.

 

With this definition an atheist is automatically excluded. Also, by this definition he is non-believer.

 

Do you see it any where in my text that I have reproached you for his exclusion from the Ummah?

 

But on what reason do you declare the Marxist and Materialist Muslims as non-believers??

 

Hope to hear from you soon.

 

Ahsan

ahsan@noos.fr    

Send questions or comments to Family of the Heart