|
"Thoughts on 'Conditioning'"
“WILLIAM Wordsworth tells us
that it is only in retrospect that one can sort out what has been most
significant, most telling, in our experience. In his epic poem The
Prelude he writes, “There are in our existence spots of time,/ Which
with distinct preeminence retain/ A renovating virtue,” and says that it
is to these “spots of time” that we return, again and again, for
emotional nourishment, for a sense of what the world is and who we
ourselves are within that world.”
from Through the prism of human
collectivity by Huck Gutman
|
Now let us see what all
this clamor about ‘conditioning’ is. According to Columbia
encyclopedia ‘conditioning’ is part of learning process and
learning is a “process by which a relatively
lasting change in potential behavior occurs as a result of
practice or experience. Learning is distinguished from behavioral
changes arising from such processes as maturation and illness, but
does apply to motor skills, such as driving a car, to intellectual
skills, such as reading, and to attitudes and values, such as
prejudice. There is evidence that neurotic symptoms and patterns
of mental illness are also learned behavior. Learning occurs
throughout life in animals, and learned behavior accounts for a
large proportion of all behavior in the higher animals, especially
in humans. |
|
The scientific investigation of the
learning process was begun at the end of the 19th cent. by Ivan
Pavlov in Russia and Edward Thorndike in the United States. Three
models are currently widely used to explain changes in learned
behavior; two emphasize the establishment of relations between
stimuli and responses, and the third emphasizes the establishment
of cognitive structures. Albert Bandura maintained (1977) that
learning occurs through observation of others, or models; it has
been suggested that this type of learning occurs when children are
exposed to violence in the media. |
|
Classical
Conditioning |
|
The first model, classical
conditioning, was initially identified by Pavlov in the salivation
reflex of dogs. Salivation is an innate reflex, or unconditioned
response, to the presentation of food, an unconditioned stimulus.
Pavlov showed that dogs could be conditioned to salivate merely to
the sound of a buzzer (a conditioned stimulus), after it was
sounded a number of times in conjunction with the presentation of
food. Learning is said to occur because salivation has been
conditioned to a new stimulus that did not elicit it initially.
The pairing of food with the buzzer acts to reinforce the buzzer
as the prominent stimulus. |
|
Operant
Conditioning |
|
A second type of learning, known as
operant conditioning, was developed around the same time as
Pavlov’s theory by Thorndike, and later expanded upon by B. F.
Skinner. Here, learning takes place as the individual acts upon
the environment. Whereas classical
conditioning involves innate reflexes, operant conditioning
requires voluntary behavior. Thorndike showed that an
intermittent reward is essential to reinforce learning, while
discontinuing the use of reinforcement tends to extinguish the
learned behavior. … Besides reinforcement, punishment produces
avoidance behavior, which appears to weaken learning but not
curtail it. In both types of conditioning, stimulus generalization
occurs; i.e., the conditioned response may be elicited by stimuli
similar to the original conditioned stimulus but not used in the
original training. Stimulus generalization has enormous practical
importance, because it allows for the application of learned
behaviors across different contexts. Behavior modification is a
type of treatment resulting from these stimulus/response models of
learning. It operates under the
assumption that if behavior can be learned,
it can also be unlearned.
|
|
Cognitive
Learning |
|
A third approach to learning is
known as cognitive learning. Wolfgang Köhler showed that
a protracted process of trial-and-error
may be replaced by a sudden understanding that grasps the
interrelationships of a problem. This process, called
insight,
is more akin to piecing together a puzzle than responding to a
stimulus. Edward Tolman (1930) found that unrewarded
rats learned the layout of a maze, yet this was not apparent until
they were later rewarded with food. Tolman called this latent
learning, and it has been suggested that the rats developed
cognitive maps of the maze that they were able to apply
immediately when a reward was offered” |
Now, if we read the above
discussion closely (please pay special attention to the colored fonts)
it can be seen that without proper critically analysis, it is easy to
become ‘deluded’ in the ‘vortex’ of terminology such as ‘conditioning’.
In other words, if we are
just product of conditioning, then from where all creativity and
ingenuity comes about? Saying that we are just product of conditioning
sounds somewhat like we are nothing more than vegetables. This is an
attitude of extreme ‘reductionism’
|